This little checklist is intended to help people score some extra points in the mapmaking competition, but it still holds true for any map. Go through the checklist and see if you fulfill at least most of the requirements.

FLOW:
[ ] - Did you avoid dead ends? If you have some, are they very short and have some kind of reward (good guns, frex)?
[ ] - Are all of your platforms properly timed and placed?
[ ] - Is every hallway at the necessary length to balance speed and looks?
[ ] - Are all of the guns in natural places, or would the player need to actively search them?
[ ] - When you use stairs in lieu of lifts, are they at good angles and not unnecessarily exposed?
[ ] - Do all of the hallways point toward the main battlefield? In other words, did you avoid mazes whenever possible?
[ ] - Do you have the least amount of deep liquids possible?
[ ] - Do your teleports bring players to relatively safe locations?
[ ] - Are the main hallways broad enough to support limited dodging (about 1 WU wide, at least)?
[ ] - Are gimmick lifts, water lifts, etc. absolutely necessary? If so, are they fast and provide some kind of benefit?
[ ] - Have you avoided sharp turns (>90 degrees) whenever possible? If they're necessary, consider using curved tunnels instead.
[ ] - Are there plenty of exits -- be they windows, doors, teleports, sniper ledges, or anything -- back to the main battleground from whatever hallways you have?
[ ] - Do you have a minimal amount of death traps (ideally 0 total)?
[ ] - Were Extravision powerups avoided entirely?
[ ] - Was 5D space avoided whenever possible? 5D to make a brief shortcut is okay, but maps like "5D Space" are bad news.
[ ] - Does your map use overlapping to a reasonable extent? Maps that overlap eight times are bad.
[ ] - Did you avoid "headbanger stairs?" I should be able to go down a flight of stairs and not hit my head on the ceiling.
[ ] - Are your stairs reasonably steep? Steps that are 0.3 WU tall are difficult to climb while focusing on the combat.
[ ] - Whenever you have a sniper ledge, can you see the surface that the ledge is intended to snipe?
[ ] - Did you avoid stupidly huge pits? Melatonin is a map that has stupidly huge pits.

BALANCE:
[ ] - Is the weapon loadout evenly placed? For example, are rockets scattered throughout the map instead of bunched together in the center?
[ ] - Is the map's arsenal reasonable -- that is, can most of the guns stand up to the map's strongest gun? Rockets and fusion only make an unbalanced arsenal.
[ ] - Are spawns placed in relatively safe locations (against walls or away from the fray) whenever possible?
[ ] - Are spawns properly spaced? Spawns should cover pretty much every area of the map, except featureless hallways.
[ ] - Can any player reach a gun in three seconds?
[ ] - Can any player reach ammo for his gun (excluding rockets and TOZT) in five seconds?
[ ] - Can you reach the hill/main battlefield in five seconds?
[ ] - Are powerups (health cans and BCEs) properly placed, and given reasonable spawn rates?
[ ] - Did you avoid 2x or 3x rechargers?
[ ] - Did you avoid invulnerability?
[ ] - Did you avoid difficult secrets?
[ ] - Do hard-to-reach areas have good payoffs without being unreasonable (i.e. that distant ledge has one of three rocket launchers, but not the ONLY rocket launcher)?
[ ] - Did you avoid any regions that provide a ridiculous advantage over all of the other players, which are very hard to reach safely? The top pool of Duality is such a place.
[ ] - (If applicable) Is the hill hard to defend without being impossible to hold? The hill on THRUD is such an example, whereas the hill on Thunderdome is too hard to hold.
[ ] - (If applicable) Are there places to run with the Ball? If so, are they so complex that nobody can find the carrier?

ARCHITECTURE AND DEPTH:
[ ] - Make sure your map doesn't look ugly. If you have to squint to look at your map, retexture it.
[ ] - Did you apply differential shading?
[ ] - Is your usage of textures reasonably varied? You don't have to use every texture, but you should use enough to make any region distinguishable from any other area.
[ ] - Are doors and teleports distinguishable from walls?
[ ] - Make sure your architecture does not ruin the flow. Flow is more important than architecture.
[ ] - Make sure your map isn't "too detailed." Marathon maps can only take so much detail before it begins to look stupid.
[ ] - Is your map detailed at all? Maps that compose entirely of featureless open rooms and hallways, regardless of the quality of texturing and lighting, suck.
[ ] - Consider using liquids "artistically." This means ankle-deep water, lava in inaccessible pits, and so on. They look great but don't tamper with flow.
[ ] - Is your map asymmetrical? Symmetry is a newbie trick. Asymmetry keeps players entertained more often and provide more advanced strategy.
[ ] - Did you use sounds? If you did, are they at reasonable volumes (80ish) and reasonably placed? Wind in an enclosed space sounds stupid.
[ ] - Did you use curves, if the map calls for it? Rigid maps are quite fine, but whenever you can, consider using curved walls instead of right angles.
[ ] - Is your lighting "unrealistic"? Realistic shading almost always sucks. A good example is Route 66 (604 or Better), but anything more complex than that tends to look bad.
[ ] - Does your ceiling space look good? Ceilings are a great place to show off your architecture without hurting flow.

ORIGINALITY
[ ] - Make sure your map doesn't immediately remind you of ONE other map.
[ ] - Make sure you used a minimum number of architecture tricks from other maps.
[ ] - Make sure your map name is interesting without being stupid. "Arena" is boring. "Circle of Tears" is a fairly good name. "Inappropriate Finger" is a stupid name.

FUN
[ ] - Test your map with other players.
[ ] - Did you find it fun?
[ ] - Did everyone else find it fun?
[ ] - Did you consider everyone's criticisms?

FUNCTIONALITY
[ ] - Make sure your map has at least 8 spawns.
[ ] - Make sure you textured every side.
[ ] - Make sure you have enough guns and ammo for your map size.
[ ] - Make sure your items respawn.
[ ] - Avoid using monsters.
[ ] - Check your map for bouncy sides, "fake walls" (solid surfaces in overlapping areas), "sticky lattices" (getting caught in a fence), or "bouncy hallways" (entering one hallway and appearing in the adjacent one), and fix them accordingly.
[ ] - Make sure you have no suicide traps (areas that don't kill you but are inescapable).
[ ] - Merge your map.
[ ] - Make sure all of the "map type" (i.e. rebellion) flags are unchecked.
[ ] - Make sure all of the desired gametypes are marked. FOR THE CONTEST, YOU WILL BE MARKED DOWN IF YOU CHECK "KING OF THE HILL" AND THE MAP SUCKS FOR KOTH OR HAS NO HILL AT ALL.
[ ] - Make sure any smearing bugs are fixed.
[ ] - Make sure you fixed any crashing bugs. Anything that can crash Aleph One is both a feat and a disaster.

What about "An Inappropriate Finger in my Arena caused a Circle of Tears?"

hey, these are nice tips! I like checklists,

if you ever come across a checklist for single player map makers, let me know, im still learning the universe of map dynamics

ROFL!

On a (sort of) unrelated note, what causes those bouncy walls and hallways? How do you fix them?

I personally think this topic should be pinned up and edited to say "Checklist for Netmap making" because also could help net mappers later on. anyone else agree?

Definitely.

ja Herr Kapitän!

Hmm...what about naming your maps after song?
Like songs you think people should be listening to while they play the map... :D

All of my newer completed maps are named after songs, I know some of irons' and RyokoTK's are too.

Yeah, several of mine are music-related. From RS:

Hocus Pocus, The Wildfire, Revontulet, and Dreadnaught are all song names:

Focus - Hocus Pocus
Sonata Arctica - Wildfire
Sonata Arctica - Revontulet
Machinae Supremacy - Dreadnaught

Also, Ecliptica, Silence, and Winterheart's Guild are all Sonata Arctica albums.

Furthermore, "Master Slave" is a line taken from Machinae Supremacy - Attack Music.

The more you know. :)

Mine we'll be named after my favourite metal songs.
form like
Trivium
Road Runner United
Slayer
System Of A Down
etc...

How about for a name ("Wing Nut Club")

"Brown-Eyed Girl"
"Stink Finger"
"Ginger Beer Trick"
"If You Don't Care Where You Are..."
"You Aren't Really Lost..."

there's also a map with many different variations called
All Along The Watchtower witch is a Jimi Hendrix song

Actually, isnt that a Bob Dylan song originally?

Also, some of Mine named after songs are:

My Body is a Cage (Arcade Fire)

Black Wave (Arcade Fire)

The Sheik of Araby (Early Beatles, don't know if they wrote it)

In The Grasslend (Also called Sheep) - The line "In the Grassland" is from a Pink Foyd song "Sheep"

I'm not sure it may have been.
I'm thinking bout making a map named
"pages out of print" which is a line from that new foo fighters song "the pretenders"
anyways it would basically be like a book with a buch of rooms stacked on top of each other with elevators or teleporters connecting them.
(really this should be in the map support/ideas forum)

u mean topic?

Some of my favorite maps I have made are named after songs. I even named my most recent maps with a certain obsession of mines

The Klaxons - Gravity's Rainbow

Aqua Times - Alones ('Oreta Awai Tsubasa' was the opening line. And no, this song is not completely in English)

Kanye West Featuring Freeway and Mos Def - Two Words

Juelz Santana - Losin My love

Nas - Just a Moment ('Moment of Silence' was the main part of the chorus)

The Game - Dreams

Jay Z - Beach Chair (not exactly my favorite to make, but it was named after a song)

All Along the Watchtower was originally a Bob Dylan song, and has been covered by like, every musician in the world. Jimi Hendrix's version is widely considered the best, though.

for YOUR contest, whatever, but to use this bs as a guide to making "good" maps?? i have noted the retardness that seeps from your genius.

no, it needs to be fixed.

I don't play online at all (because I'm terrible), but even I can see the problem with one-man netmaps.

I didn't see his first post in this thread before responding in the other, but, I think we're being trolled.

I'll give you that. but there are some things that are opinion and not techniques. we need a revised list that's JUST good map-making habits. which this mostly is.

Anytime someone says a practice is good or bad it's an opinion, get over yourself.

Oh giddy :D

Get your shoes on, we're going for a troll stroll.

I think that what people need to do more often is make more original, not necessarily gimmicky, maps and map-packs. Merged physics, shape files, and MML/LUA were invented for a reason. Even if it was crude, my Zombies! mod was pretty fun to play with friends, and all you needed to play was... Nothing. The whole mod was merged into a single map file, no major changes to the engine, just some different weapons, zombie BOBs, and carnage.

I'm thinking about reinstating weekly map as a Bi-Weekly map event (gives me more time) even if my 1st week M1A1 maps were not necessarily bad. (according to the little amount of response I got for it)
I also think that shuttling some of the map traffic to other scenarios is good for the community, nobody feels left out because they can play the online experience with any scenario, for example, Rubicon is dead for multiplayer practically, and it's like pulling teeth to get an M1A1 game going, even if you pre-inform the community.

That's because the net play in those games sucks, even if you pre-inform the community.

I had a lot of fun in M1A1. It sucks that nobody makes maps for it, but I like it. The guns are all powerful but they aren't so imbalanced that there's any unexpected god gun, all of them are a case of "at least this powerful".
As far as Rubicon goes, once someone has a Maser, Carpet Mortar, and SPNKr, any faith in religion can be stripped from even the pope.

Ohhh Kaaayyy.

That was one of patrick's more overt (but still awesome) responses. He's trying to help you out, but can only go so far.

OH I SEE IT! Wow, a dude is pointing a Maser at the pope, I barely recognized it.
Thanks patrick.

Okei U can haz hugz nao